Thursday morning. The shop phone rings. It is the lady who orders the same things from your online shop every month. «I can’t get in again», she says. «I clicked where it says I forgot my password, but nothing came».

It is the third time this year. The first time you told her to check her spam folder. The second time, she created a new account with her daughter’s email, and now her orders are split across two accounts. This time you tell her «just tell me what you need and I’ll put the order through myself».

The order was rescued. But think about what happened: an online shop built to take orders without you needed you to take one.

The customer who phones is the lucky one

This lady knows you and trusts you, so she phoned you. Most customers do not. They close the page and shop elsewhere, or leave the order for «later», which usually never comes.

The Baymard Institute, which studies how people shop online, has seen it in its usability testing of large online shops. Of the people who tried to sign in to an account they already had, almost one in five did not complete the purchase in the end, because they had forgotten their password and got stuck resetting it. Most of them gave up waiting for an email that was delayed or had gone to spam. In other words, customers who had already chosen the shop, not strangers who were hesitating.

The problem is not limited to online shops. The same thing happens on the page where a customer downloads their invoices, in a booking system, in the area where your trade partners see wholesale prices. Wherever you ask for a password, someone will forget it.

First question: is an account needed at all?

The password that is never forgotten is the one that was never asked for. Before anything else, then, it is worth asking what the customer gains from the account.

In an online shop, someone buying once usually gains nothing. That is why buying without an account, as a guest, has to exist and has to be visible. I have set out the figures for this in the article on cart abandonment, and I will not repeat them here.

For people who come back, though, an account makes sense: they see what they ordered last time, reorder it with one click, find their invoices. The lady from the beginning wants an account. What she does not want is to remember a password.

And those two no longer have to go together.

The rules that make passwords easy to forget

First, though, let’s look at where the problem starts. Many sites require a password with at least one capital letter, one number and one symbol. Some require a change every few months. Others do not allow pasting into the password field, so anyone who has it saved on their phone has to type it in letter by letter. All of this was put there for security. In practice, the customer makes up something like «Maria2024!», cannot remember it three months later, and clicks «forgot password».

NIST, the US standards institute, writes the sign-in rules for US government services, and many others use them as a point of reference. The new edition of these rules, finalised in July 2025, says it plainly: composition rules, such as the capital letter, the number and the symbol, must not be imposed. Nor should people be forced to change their password at regular intervals, unless there is evidence that it has leaked. And password managers, the programs that save and fill in passwords, must be allowed. What it asks for instead is a password that is long enough (even a whole phrase), and a check that it is not one that is very common or has already leaked.

In other words, the rules that make a password hard to remember do not necessarily make it more secure. They just make it more likely that the customer clicks «forgot password».

Signing in without a password

Today there are ways for a customer to get into their account without remembering anything.

The first is the simplest. The customer types their email address, and the site sends them a link or a one-time code, a few digits that are valid for a few minutes and that they do not need to remember. They click the link or type the digits, and they are in. Every sign-in is essentially a «forgot password», except that they do not have to set a new one. There is one condition, though: the site’s emails have to arrive, and arrive quickly.

The second is called a passkey. The customer signs in the way they unlock their phone: with a fingerprint, their face or the device PIN. There is no password to forget, and no password that someone could trick out of them with a fake email. Passkeys are now supported by modern iPhone and Android phones and by Windows and Mac computers. The FIDO Alliance, the organisation that promotes signing in without passwords, asked nine of its member companies that use them. They reported up to 81% fewer support requests about sign-in problems. These are figures the companies reported themselves, not an independent measurement. But they show where things are heading.

The third is signing in with the Google or Apple account the customer already has. It is convenient, as long as it is not the only option, because not everyone has such an account, and not everyone wants to connect it to a shop.

You do not need all three. What you need is for the customer to get in without having to remember something they will forget. Which method fits depends on who your customers are and which system your site is built with.

When the customer clicks «forgot password»

As long as there are passwords, this button will be there too. And this is where the customer either stays or leaves.

The first problem is the email that never comes. The lady from the beginning did not create a second account out of carelessness. She created it because the password reset email never reached her. Usually it has gone to spam, or never arrived at all, because the site sends its emails in a way that email providers such as Gmail and Outlook do not trust. I explain why this happens in «Why your emails land in the spam folder». A site that sends sign-in links, password reset links and order confirmations has to be sure that its messages arrive.

The second is the way back in. Every extra step, every link that does not open on the device where the customer read the email, every cart that is lost along the way, is one more chance for them to give up and shop elsewhere.

The third is who knows your customers’ passwords. The right answer is nobody, not even you. If, when a customer phones, you set a password for them and give it to them over the phone, then anyone who calls claiming to be your customer can get into their account and see their orders, addresses and details. In «Someone is speaking in your name» I write about someone pretending to be you. Here someone is pretending to be your customer. On the phone, what you should do instead is resend the password reset link to the email address they have already registered, not to whichever one they give you at that moment. If it still does not arrive, the problem is in the site, not with the customer, and it is a matter for whoever looks after it.

And to avoid any confusion: all of this is about your customers. For the accounts you yourself use to manage your site and your email, two-step verification, meaning a password plus a confirmation on your phone, is essential, as I write in the same article.

One sign is enough

If even one customer has told you that the password reset email never arrived, they are not the only one it happened to. They are the only one who told you.

Whatever stopped them stops the rest of your customers too. The difference is that they will not tell you.

Third time

The lady from the beginning will never tell you that your site is difficult. She will say «it’s my fault, I’m no good with these things». And one day when she is in a hurry, and you cannot pick up the phone, she will order from somewhere where she does not have to remember anything.

It is not her fault. Nobody remembers passwords. A site that has taken this into account does not ask the customer to remember, and does not ask you to put their orders through.

If your customers phone you because they cannot get in, or if you do not know what someone finds when they click «forgot password» on your site, we will look at it with you and give you our findings in writing. When we build a site or a web application ourselves, customer sign-in is designed from the start so that it does not need you. Send us your website address through the contact form.

The whole picture: this article covers one part of a larger subject. If you are after the whole of it, from commissioning to replacement, it is in the guide to your website.